MasterChef: The Professionals 2026 2: Hypercube, Episode 9: Mythical Hot Chocolate Soup

There is nothing I love in this world more than a shot of a singular cinematic tear.

Wanted: Full-time Fish Gravy Expert.

You’re Taking The Pistachios

For this week’s Mystery Ingredient Challenge, the chefs were working with the three genders of pistachio: Green, Raw and Paste

how very modern and on trend of them

clock them, Abigail. Unfortunately the Ritter Sport Pistachio Chocolate is my kryptonite and I am powerless against it if I walk within the vicinity of the singular Sainsbury’s Local that stocks it in Sheffield

it very much feels like a challenge designed to get everyone to make a pudding again after the Signature Dessert Challenge was a bit of a dud this week, but of course there were savoury options on offer like lamb, chicken and fish

or at least they were on offer very briefly before Dominique started hauling everything back to her bench like she was moving house

she just kept going back for more and more things leaving Marcus and Monica to stare on like confused neighbours who don’t know if they should offer to help or not

well, it’s a good thing nobody else wanted to do a main course, isn’t it?

I admire the gutsiness of going for a main course in a challenge that is more geared towards a dessert but this was absolutely a trap that Dominique unfortunately stepped right into because really, your only option is to make a pistachio crumb? Which is exactly what she did. Twice.

it was a nice enough dish: the lamb was cooked beautifully and the Sausage Meat and Ricotta Tartlet was tasty! It just wasn’t showcasing the pistachio in an exciting enough way, the most inventive and intriguing part of the dish was her use of Raspberry in the Lamb Jus that was a surprising success for the judges

and Andrea had kind of the same issue with his dessert, the Pistachio Crème Pâtissier was a little bit too expected and the most interesting part of the dish was the Basil Frozen Yoghurt on the side

and the judges also had a bit of an issue with the proportions, he maybe needed another layer of the pastry but perhaps that’s just the Italian variant he’d made up right now

perhaps that’s just how they Mille and Feuille in Syracuse? If so, he certainly could’ve afforded to add more of the Pistachio Biscuit Crumb that he had a gargantuan amount of leftover

I love it when they cater for the crew and the crew’s family.

Connor’s layered dessert was also quite hit and miss, the judges seemed to prefer it over Andrea’s and I think it was mostly the case of it felt a little bit more improvised and spur of the moment with the Rosewater-infused Strawberries that complimented the Pistachio Mousse that had quite a powerful kick of pistachio

it is however not really a complete dish and needs just one more element like a brittle or praline. The presentation doesn’t seem particularly well thought out either and I think a flatter plate to spread things out would’ve been better than this quite steep soup bowl.

Abigail had the greatest success with this round and went into it determined to make up for the fact she hadn’t executed the Signature Dessert to a standard that she had wanted

she was going for a chocolate dessert, somewhat similar to a Chocolate Fondant but flatter and baked in a dog bowl

her biggest worry was that because she was cooking it on quite a low temperature, that it wouldn’t set in time and end up being more of a Hot Chocolate Soup

which means I once again have to mention the time in a rainy Cornish car park we made my brother go and ask the food truck parked there for the “hot chocolate soup” because the menu was written like this

Hot Chocolate
Soup
£1

and he walked back to the car, face glowing red as the woman in the van scream laughed like thunder itself as he told us “It’s just Hot Chocolate and Soup.” We’ve never let him live it down, even though we all thought the same thing.
Fortunately for Marcus and Monica, they did not end up getting the mythical hot chocolate soup so my family quest shall continue

it was a really good dessert with the Pistachio notes being enhanced by the Dark Chocolate and Raspberries

An Unofficial Pistachio Dish Ranking:
1. Abigail’s Solid Hot Chocolate
2. Andrea’s Meuillo Feuillo
3. Connor’s Bowl of Partially Thought Out Ideas
4. Dominique’s Pistachio Crusted Bear Trap

Everyone’s A Critic

This week’s critics were Jimi Famurewa, William Sitwell and new to the chamber, Ixta Belfrage who came dressed to lead a resistance group in the Hunger Games universe

and as ever the critics would be judging the chefs 2 course menus for which desserts are strictly outlawed for some reason and I would love the know the logic behind it! Did they just get bored of everyone making Chocolate Fondants or did they realise that given the opportunity to not make a dessert, just about every chef would jump at the chance? Or maybe it was the ever increasing price of butter? And if that is the case, Connor has some bad news for the MasterChef accountant

the butter with a hint of Jersey Royals was part of his starter which was a mussel dish that was finished with a mussel sauce and at least some of the butter

the critics could not have raved about this dish more – they really thought it was the best thing since sliced bread which was a very high bar for Connor to set with the first dish of the challenge. He managed to keep the momentum going with his Venison Loin main course that was served with black pudding stuffed morels and roasted beetroot

the redness of it does somewhat take you aback slightly, so thank God for that splash of green – Abigail could really have done with some of that for her Chicken Ballotine that looked like The Great Ship Beige Dinner sailing straight for you at a rate of knots

everyone really struggled with this plate of food because it just lacked dimension and was a bit like being relentlessly clobbered over the head with a chicken fillet and everyone was in desperate need of a reprieve – although William Sitwell was very taken with the crispy chicken skin

but he does have the look of someone who has a penchant for skin

I do also think the disappointment for Abigail’s main course was partly as a result of everyone having thought so highly of her starter, which was Red Mullet on Toast with a Bouillabaisse Sauce

and if Abigail wants it, there’s a job going as William Sitwell’s personal Skin and Fish Gravy Chef

you cook the crispy chicken skin, or else you get the hose again!

Andrea and Dominique had both opted for cured starters. Andrea continued his celebration of Sicilian cuisine with a Red Prawn Carpaccio that looked very fresh and vibrant

the problem it kind of runs into is that yes the ingredients are lovely and and beautifully presented but this is a cookery competition and a really nice little dinner roll on the side is very hard to base a judgement on

and the one element that everyone was super excited about, the Red Prawn Mayonnaise, was just not there in a big enough proportion to have the impact it ought to have had. Dominique’s Korean Yukhoe was not without faults of it own as her crispy capers didn’t manage to make it onto the plate

but at least without them, the dish still worked because the Nori Taro Crisps on the side brought in both the textural crunch the dish needs and that briny saltiness the capers would’ve added

so the dish still felt like a complete dish.

Proportions continued to be a bit of a problem with Andrea going into his “main course” which was Veal Cheek Tortelloni and very much a “main course” in name only because even in the world of fine dining I’m not sure 3 pieces of pasta is going to cut it

the judges can be quite picky and choosey when it comes to taking issue with portion sizes on this show (and it infuriates me no end) but usually even the itsy bitsiest plates of fine dining at least have a few more elements to create ~an experience~ – this is just pasta in an overwhelming sauce

and it really runs into the problem that putting only three things on a plate does, in that it looks like the face of a clown you see in recurring dreams in which your nails all fall off

but for a moment it looked like Andrea might scrape by because the plate of stone bass that Dominique had served to Marcus and Monica could have been released back into the Atlantic Ocean for spawning season

but they declared that if the critics all at least got cooked fish, they were going to be happy with that… which is *very* generous and felt like they just kind of wanted to sunset Andrea lol

but I also get it because Dominique is bringing food and flavours we don’t see a lot of on Masterchef and this main course is kind of the peak of that: a Stone Bass seasoned with a Somalian spice mix called Xawaash and served with Yassa Soubise – which is a fusion between a Senegalese and classic French sauce

it’s a stunning mix of East and West African ingredients with European techniques that creates a very exciting and memorable dish. The critics all have a good few decades of combined experience between them and all felt like they’d never quite had food like Dominique’s.

An Unofficial Two Course Menu Dish Ranking:
1. We’re Ignore The Raw Elephant In The Room
2. Would You Like Some Mussels With Your Butter?
3. William Sitwell’s Personal Fish Gravier
4. Are You Winning, Venison?
5. There’s Some Yukhoe In This House
6. Putting The Raw in Prawns
7. Voyage of the Beige Brown Treader
8. But Doctor, I Am The Great Clown Tortelloni

Connor was the only one that was safe as houses after the Critics Challenge – both of his dishes were absolutely perfect. The others all had some issues with their main courses but ultimately it was Andrea who was being let go

I’ve really enjoyed him and will miss his constant drive-by trilling that was visibly annoying Marcus at every turn <3

he’s just singing the song of his people!

If you have enjoyed this recap and would like to show your appreciation, you can leave a small donation via my Ko-fi HERE. I am currently saving up for Facial Feminisation Surgery, which all tips will be going towards and are much appreciated!

Leave a Reply