Bake Off 2026, Caramel Week: Strong Female Apples

One day all of this will belong to you.

It took a while for my caramel to set.

Ey Up, Treacle!

We begin Sugary Disaster Week with the bakers having to fuss up a dessert that ought never be fussed up as they had to make a uniquely flavoured and beautifully decorated Treacle Tart

although I don’t know if the treacle Tart actually had to have a unique flavour but it felt like an unspoken rule. A more bona fide rule was that they also had to serve it with an accompaniment of their choice and because this is Dying In A Pool of Molten Sugar Like A Dinosaur In A Tar Pit Week, they were also being asked to make Golden Syrup from scratch because Bake Off ended its sponsorship with Lyle’s about three brand deals ago – which in the Calendar of Mo, puts it somewhere in the Japanese Edo period

we have to stop the Nara Smith-ification of Bake Off before it’s too late and they all have to start milling their own flour, refining their own sugar and accidentally starting a secluded religious commune in the woods

and if you’re wondering who the high priest of this latest wave of baking paganism is, it’s Gabe whose Almond and Orange Treacle Tart looked like the result of me trying to scratch pentagrams into the desks of my GCSE maths classroom because I was GOING THROUGH IT

Gabe was first up in the judging and the judges, somewhat oddly given they knew Mo had Trojan Horsed an Apple Crumble into this challenge for the soul reason of wanting to make his favourite flavour of ice cream, declared that there was “a lot going on” with Gabe’s tart

and the problem seemed to mostly be that Gabe had committed the cardinal Bake Off sin of using even just the lightest touch of Almond Extract

Paul’s soul left his body when Gabe accidentally said “tablespoon” <3

I need a journalistic sting operation to uncover what the bad blood is between Paul Hollywood and the Nielsen-Massey vanilla company because it was half a teaspoon in a treacle tart, I DOUBT it made that big a difference

I reckon we could honeytrap him with a decently enough made ciabatta.

Tom’s and Mo’s Treacle Tarts were probably the furthest removed from the very notion of a Treacle Tart having been Frankensteined together from the parts of other dessert options – a PB&J Sandwich makes a lovely after dinner treat!

the Peanut Butter and [Insert Jam of Choice Here But There Are Right and Wrong Answers] runs into the same problem it always does on a British cookery show, which is that it’s less of an institution here so doesn’t get met with the warm nostalgia that something like Connie invoking the British love of horrible custard does

my school dinner nostalgia is boarding school in Zimbabwe where the only decent meal they made was French Toast for breakfast on Tuesdays to lull you into a false sense of security that maybe everything would be ok this time! Then Wednesday would roll around and you’d be served a bowl of diced Vienna Sausages in a soup the colour of depressed dishwater.
Sorry, before I started trauma dumping about the culinary abominations of a Zimbabwean school that seemingly spent all its money building an endless amount of sports pavilions instead of normal food, we were discussing Tom’s Not Really A Treacle Tart At All

Mo’s Treacle Amalgamation was a little more positively received, or at least the fusion of a Treacle Tart and an Apple Crumble sat a little better with the judges

they had a few issues with his choice of apples – Mo was going to use just Pink Lady Apples but then he watched two whole TikToks about apple cultivars and threw in a couple of Granny Smiths to make it a celebration of strong female apples

but really the whole thing was very much playing second fiddle to his accompaniment of choice which was a Brown Butter Pecan Ice Cream that is constantly on his mind like Bianca Jackson’s wedding scrunchie is on mine

alas, they keep making him make all these peasant dishes from the late 18th century medieval period instead of something modern and funky like… what are the kids baking these days? All I see is Girl Dinner and it’s like edamame beans, a pack of cigarettes and a can of Ultra Rosa Monster

you better believe I looked up when the first mention of a treacle tart was and was absolutely thrilled to find out it’s in a court summons for a woman whose dog bit someone

giving Mo’s dessert an average date of origin of 1872 because the Fannie Farmer Cookbook really missed the boat in 1896 and would’ve brought the date down a good 10 years

there’s enough well know culinary icons called Fannie or Fanny for us to have an official Fanny Week on this show BUT THEY’RE TOO COWARDLY

I am millennial cringe, but i am free.

The one major critique levelled at Mo for his Treacle Crumble was that it was too sweet which given the nature of the challenge I don’t think really holds up in a court of law, so CASE DISMISSED. He did also have a soggy bottom situation with the apples creating that much more moisture that even blind baking couldn’t really keep it at bay

he wasn’t the only one, Connie also had a soggy bottom with her treacle tart

but despite the lack of success with her pastry case, the filling of her treacle tart was probably the closest to what the judges were expecting and they loved the decoration, or at least Nigella loved the potential for violence that it held

the first rule of Bake Off Fight Club is that we don’t talk about Bake Off Fight Club. Ironically, speaking of things we don’t talk about, unfortunately we have to declare this episode Not Safe From Harry Potter Content™

apparently Treacle Tart is Magical Scarface’s favourite dessert and Moyin was blending it with a Sticky Toffee Pudding because it and Treacle Tart are like second cousins once removed so the flavour profiles go together quite well. If anything I was surprised that the judges didn’t think it was too sweet.
Come the judging they had also used up all their fair use mentions of Harry Potter so in order to prevent the few lawyers Rowling has that aren’t distracted by making the lives of trans people worse in every possible way imaginable coming down on them like a tone of mould riddled bricks to protect The Sanctity of Brand

the tart was now just Paul’s son

or the Aladdin Sane album cover

ally ✊

An Unofficial Signature Treacle Tart Ranking:
1. Hatsune Miku’s Legally Distinct Orphan Wizard
2. Gabe’s Essence of The Old Gods Treacle Tart
3. Tom’s PB&Just About A Treacle Tart
4. Mo’s Anglo Saxon Apple Slop
5. Connie vs Nigella In The Car Park

Eat The Rich

For their Caramel Week Technical Challenge, the bakers were having to make Millionaire’s Shortbread which I think was quite a good challenge because at least following the Iced Gems technical in Biscuit Week, they’ve had experience with baking shortbread already. However, there end the nice things I have to say because they only had 90 minutes

and with three elements to set and cool – the shortbread, the salted caramel and the marbled chocolate it just was obviously not going to be entirely possible, no matter how friendly the fridges felt

the fridge may be a friend, but the blender is always a foe

and even with the help of the fridges, everyone was still having to blast their shortbreads, caramels and chocolate with the freeze sprays like they were trying to put out wildfires

we have strayed too far from the light of God.

Given the week’s theme, it was mostly a test to see if the bakers knew how to make a caramel and for the most part, everyone managed to achieve the very specific shade of brown that Nigella wanted for her bedroom the caramel

I believe that puts it at an Auburn Falls 1 but you could probably get away with Flame Frenzy 2

I think only Connie had to start hers over again as following her saying, very sagely, that whatever you do when making caramel DO. NOT. MOVE. THE. SUGAR.

they immediately smash cut to her jostling her sugar like she’s panning for gold in a 19th century boomtown so she had to start again which really hampers you on a time limit of only 90 minutes. She wasn’t the only one to be really against time as she and Mo became victims of the Slow Pan of Humiliation

Connie ended up inching just ahead of Mo because she at least had a discernible caramel, Mo’s had ended up just becoming an unidentifiable millionaires soup

oh, sorry, an apostrophe makes all the difference: unidentifiable millionaire’s soup

I cannot tell a lie, I would still go to absolute town on this.

Tom, Gabe and Moyin all had better luck with getting things set in time. Ultimately it was at the cost of underbaking their shortbreads with all of them being a bit soft. Gabe ended up in third place because his biscuits were too crumbly, making the bake overly “sandy” in texture

and because he was unfortunately silencing women

#GabeIsOverParty

With Moyin and Tom there was less of a distinct divide between the two of them. I did think Moyin was going to take it just because they were quite complimentary of the potential in his shortbread despite it being underbaked

but the win went to Tom instead

it was honestly just a bit of a coin toss and I think it would make sense for either one of them to have won.

An Official Millionaire’s Shortbread Technical Ranking:
1. Tom’s Billionaire’s Shortbread
2. Moyin’s Multi-millionaire’s Shortbread
3. Gabe’s Caramel Hedge Fund
4. Connie’s Shortbread Can’t Afford Rent
5. Mo’s Millionaire’s Soup

All For Nougatine

For the Showstopper everything was getting a little bit Bake Off: The Professionals with the bakers having to create a sugary structure. The building material of choice being Nougatine (or Nuggetine if you’re Paul) and because they remembered this is Bake Off and there ought to be some baking, there also had to be a cake hidden in there somewhere, so they gestured vaguely towards the concept of praline and wished them luck

and my GOD were they going to need it with only 4 hours to build something out of nuts and sugar that wanted nothing more than to die at the most inopportune moments

but at least it feeds the clean up crew that operates at the bottom of the Bake Off ocean waiting for their whalefall

so I can fully understand why Connie descended into flopping around like the Octopus on last night’s Blue Planet trying to catch a fish

and because the Nigella Lawson hiring fee ate the contestant welfare budget, all interventive options have been outsourced to The Paul Hollywood TAKE A WALK Foundation, and told her to, like track 8 on Crazy Town’s sophomore Album “Darkhorse”, take it to the bridge

and it did seem to do her a lot of good, or at least she completed the challenge at the slight loss of the “decorative icing” that would’ve elevated her box from being just a box

it is just unfortunately kind of a little too basic when you’ve got Tom building a pub and Gabe creating the sort of folk art you only find in a little Peak District art gallery and costs like three grand

but I do think Connie had the best pudding – she’d opted for a Hazelnut cake with matching praline and feuilletine layers

it’s a cake worth being revealed too – everyone else had just gone with quite simple opera cakes, which again I think is just a time mitigating factor and I’m sure Tom had wanted his reveal to have a little more wow-factor than this

well, I guess that’s a sticky floor so that settles the argument as to whether it’s a pub or not

he’d opted for a pub because of the Otley Run in Leeds. Which he has done, and was dressed up as Demi Moore during her The Substance awards campaigning season

he’s so pretty it’s given my gender dysphoria gender dysphoria.

It wasn’t Tom’s best bake, his sponge was a little too chewy and he clearly hadn’t managed to finish fully decorating the pub because he continues to suffer somewhat from Wrong Size of Idea Syndrome

I was also worried when Gabe started with his grand plans of creating a nougatine boat, but as we saw, it was kind of an impressive build

his cake wasn’t a resounding success with the judges – they thought it tasted kind of one note with the White Chocolate washing everything else out. I was more put off by the Blue Mirror Glaze that looked like it was sensory play slime

but that’s not really a problem exclusive to Gabe, it’s more just mirror glaze in general but the blue at least makes it look *fun* and not… Like something you find growing off the base of a tree in the woods and poke with a stick

maybe that’s too specific – visiting The Blob was a key after school activity during year 8 and then one day it vanished and our entire friendship group fell apart over it. You would not BELIEVE the horrible things we wrote about each other on Bebo. Top 8s fell apart overnight, I distinctly remember someone being accused of fancying Mr. Tang the support teacher’s moustache. High school is insane, it’s a miracle anyone survives it.

MOVING ON! Mo, like Connie, was also doing a box structure however he’d decorated his with bows and choux buns for a baby shower theme

it’s very good and definitely the level of ornate over the top decoration the judges were looking for. I also really liked that he’d made a dessert that perfectly fit the size of the box

I think that was the only thing that I was slightly disappointed by with Moyin’s – his sculpture looks so ornate and bombastic, like a relic used to summon an ancient Mesopotamian deity that threatens world domination

but the cake is so understated

Nigella and Paul didn’t seem to mind that much because it did pack quite a bit of flavour, although Paul thought Dark Chocolate would’ve been a better choice to go with the hazelnut

and Moyin took that advice like he wanted to know where Connie kept the pastry knuckledusters

TAKE HIM OUT, KING!

An Unofficial Nougatine Structure Ranking:
1. Moyin’s Ancient Nougatine Relic
2. That’s Nougatine, Baby!
3. Gabe’s Re-return of the Obra Dinn
4. Tom’s Canonically Necessary Sticky Floors
5. Sometimes a Box is Just A Box

And now we come to some of the most beautiful, heartbreaking and uplifting television of the year as Moyin finally gets that Star Baker he’s constantly been on the cusp of getting!

I’m so happy for him and can’t believe he’s achieved the impressive feat of getting Star Baker in an episode he didn’t make a Signature bake in!

and after the entire episode really emphasising his and Connie’s incredibly close bond

unfortunately, it’s complete devastation in the tent as the judges decide that they’re sending Connie home

ultimately a fair decision but good God it hurt to watch Moyin utterly beside himself while Connie motored about the tent hugging all of the crew <3

she really is the best of us and I’m so glad we got to meet Connie Christ

praise be.

If you have enjoyed this recap and would like to show your appreciation, you can leave a small donation via my Ko-fi HERE. I am currently saving up for Facial Feminisation Surgery, which all tips will be going towards and are much appreciated!

Leave a Reply